Have you ever found yourself captivated by the enchanting allure of Bali? Perhaps you’ve visited this island paradise and, amidst its breathtaking beaches and lush landscapes, dreamed of owning your own slice of heaven or renting a cozy retreat to call home. You’re not alone!
Many are drawn to Bali’s serene ambiance, vibrant culture, and promising real estate opportunities. As this interest grows, so does the debate: Is it more advantageous to rent or buy property on this wonderful island? Regardless of whether you’re a tourist or digital nomad considering a temporary stay or an expat searching for your second home and a long-term property to invest in, understanding the dynamics of Bali’s property market is essential. To give you insights, this guide delves into the key considerations, legalities, and financial implications of renting vs. buying property in Bali, helping you make an informed decision about your future in this tropical haven.
Can Foreigners Rent or Buy Property in Bali?
Bali is an attractive destination for expats seeking to invest in property. And yes, foreigners can definitely rent or buy property in Bali. However, the process for foreigners to own or rent property in Indonesia is governed by strict regulations to safeguard the interests of the country and its citizens. Understanding these rules is essential for anyone considering such an investment
Legal Framework for Foreign Property Ownership
Indonesia’s property laws are nuanced, especially concerning foreign ownership. By the “Prohibition of Land Alienation” principle, foreigners are not allowed to own freehold land in the country. Instead, they are given usufructuary rights, and that is only through the Hak Pakai or the “Right to Use” title, which is the only property title a foreign investor or property seeker can get. Alternatively, foreigners can form a foreign investment company PT PMA and buy property under the Hak Guna Bangunana or the “Right to Build” title.
This legal structure is laid out in Act No. 5/1960, known as the “Basic Agrarian Law,” which has been further shaped by additional government regulations and decrees, such as Government Regulation No. 41 in 1996, which was later replaced by Government Regulation No. 103 in 2015.
Own your COCO property in paradise with benefits for life
- +200 properties in construction
- +250 properties in full operation
- Pay 20% of your property straight from rental profit
Property Type, Location, and Validity
Although granted ownership rights under specific conditions, foreign ownership in Bali is still limited to high-end residential properties (e.g., villas, condominiums) and apartments, with minimum price thresholds set by the government to ensure substantial investments. These thresholds vary by region, aiming to align foreign investment with Indonesia’s economic goals.
Most of the time, to purchase a property, foreigners must invest at least IDR 10 billion (around USD 650,000) and have paid-up capital of IDR 2.5 billion (about USD 167,000) on the property they want to own or rent. They must also establish a PT PMA (a foreign-owned company) with a minimum capital of USD 170,000, and have an Indonesian shareholder.
Government Regulation No. 103 of 2015 further mandates the acquisition of a property through a Right to Use Certificate, granting usage rights for an initial 30 years, extendable by 20 years and renewable for another 30 years, totaling up to 80 years. However, with this consent are few limitations on the property location so as to preserve Bali’s cultural heritage and local community integrity, with certain areas reserved for local populations only. Not just that, rental income from properties owned through PT PMA is also subject to a 10% tax for tax residents and 20% for non-tax residents. These rules guarantee that international investments benefit the economy while protecting Bali’s cultural and strategic values.
Eligibility Criteria
Non-Indonesians wishing to acquire property in Bali are required to fulfill particular eligibility requirements established by the Indonesian authorities
- Nationality and Income: Foreign buyers must demonstrate financial capability, providing proof of sufficient income or assets to maintain the property. This ensures their investment benefits the local economy.
- Visa Status: Typically, a long-term visa like KITAS (Temporary Stay Permit) or KITAP (Permanent Stay Permit) is necessary. These visas allow foreigners to live in Indonesia for longer durations, making them eligible for property transactions.
- Stay Duration: Property ownership is often tied to the validity of the foreigner’s stay permit. Lease or ownership rights are typically valid only as long as the foreigner holds a valid stay permit.
Transform Your Life With a Lifestyle Investment
Take control of your future by owning property in Bali. It’s not just an investment; it’s a lifestyle upgrade that balances work, leisure, and global living
Should I Buy or Rent Property in Bali?
The choice between buying and renting property in Bali depends on several factors, including financial resources, lifestyle preferences, and long-term plans.
If you are planning to snag your own property on this priced island, we’ve got some good news! The Indonesian government has updated its luxury goods (PPnBM) tax policy for properties. Under the previous regulations, apartments and houses costing at least IDR 10 billion and IDR 20 billion, respectively, were taxed at a 20% rate. Now, the threshold was raised to IDR 30 billion for all property types to encourage property ownership from the foreign nationals and revive the declining luxury property sector. So, if you’re planning to buy or rent a property in Bali, this might be your chance to tap onto the market.
If you wish to operate your property–villas, homestays, or vacation homes with at least 3 rooms–into commercial and rental places other than using it as your personal home, you must also need to have the Pondok Wisata or the “Homestay Operational” license. Without this, you are not allowed to make your property a vacation rental. But note that this license is only given to an Indonesian citizen or foreigners owning a property under a PT PMA. So, if you’re a foreign owner, work with legal and property experts to know your way around this matter.
Property Options in Bali: Which is the Most Cost-Effective Decision?
When deciding between buying or renting property in Bali, evaluating different property types is crucial to making a cost-effective decision. Here’s a detailed look at the main options:
Ready-Made Properties
These are pre-built and often fully furnished properties that are ready for immediate occupancy. They offer the advantage of convenience and time savings, as there is no waiting period for construction. Ready-made properties are ideal for those who want to avoid the complexities of building or renovating. However, this convenience usually comes with a higher price tag, reflecting the premium on immediate availability and the reduced need for further investment in furnishing or finishing.
Off Plan Properties
Purchasing off-plan means buying a property that is either under construction or yet to be built. This option often comes at a lower initial cost compared to ready-made properties. Buyers also have the opportunity to customize the property to their liking. However, this approach carries risks, such as construction delays or changes in the final product. The lower initial price might be offset by these uncertainties and potential additional costs during the building process.
Secondary Market Properties
These are existing properties that are resold by current owners. Secondary market properties can offer competitive prices, sometimes lower than new or ready-made properties. Buyers can often find well-maintained properties in desirable locations, sometimes with established rental income. However, the condition of these properties may vary, and buyers should account for possible renovation costs. Additionally, due diligence is essential to ensure that the property has no legal issues or significant maintenance concerns.
If you ever choose to renovate, you must account for your property’s size, location, and materials used. Renovations can breathe new life into older properties, potentially increasing their value and rental appeal. However, managing construction or renovation projects in Bali can be complex and requires thorough planning and reliable contractors.
why investors choose
coco development group?
Passive income on full auto pilot
COCO Development Group take care
all of the matters relating to the lease of your villa
Profit Maximization
We do not just put your property on Airbnb hoping for a guest to book it. More than 40% of our bookings comes today through our own medias, a strong community and a digital and data driven management approach.
A Convenient and fast payment system
The investors receive net profits currency that is convenient for them. we transfer the money once every three months
No need to handle taxes
COCO Development Group deals with accounting, optimization and payment of taxes. we take care of
everything, you just get the money deposited into your account
High Liquidity
We choose the best locations in Bali and don´t just build villas, but create destinations, conceptual complexes with residential and growth. Based on our experience, we can predict an increase in property values by 35% after the construction is completed.
Fast Payback
Oceanside villas in Bali are in High demand for daily rentals. You will earn about 5000 USD per month
Buying a Property in Bali
Sure, buying a property is very much appealing, especially among expats and retirees seeking a new home on the island, as it offers more control, stability, and potential financial gains. Though it may come with a hefty price tag compared to renting, the long-term benefits outweigh several disadvantages. So, here’s what makes buying a property in Bali an attractive option:
- Long-term Financial Gains and Investment Opportunity: Property in Bali may increase in value over time, offering potential capital appreciation. Putting money into real estate can be a smart long-term approach, particularly in desirable areas where demand continues to rise.
- Stable Rental Income: The villas and apartments in Bali attract many tourists and expatriates, providing the owner with an opportunity for stable rental income. The island’s tourism is strong, providing a consistent demand for both short-term and long-term rentals.
- Stability and Safety: Having a property offers a feeling of permanence and safety, making it perfect for individuals intending to stay long-term or establish Bali as their main home.
- Personalization: Owning property provides increased flexibility for personal expression in terms of customization, renovations, and overall use.
- Long-Term Savings: Once the property is paid off, you eliminate housing expenses, making it more economical than renting as time goes on.
- Lifestyle Benefits: Owning a home in Bali provides personal space and the opportunity to experience the distinctive lifestyle without the limitations typically associated with a rental contract. It’s perfect for anyone seeking to reside there for an extended period, engaged with the local community, or desiring a peaceful retirement in a tropical paradise.
However, despite the benefits, there are also challenges associated with purchasing property:
- Complex Legal Processes and Requirements: Navigating Indonesia’s legal system can be complex for foreign buyers. The process involves understanding and complying with various regulations, such as property ownership laws and the need for a Right to Use and Right to Build certificates. This complexity can be daunting and may require professional legal assistance.
- High Maintenance and Ongoing Costs: Property ownership comes with ongoing responsibilities, including maintenance, repairs, and management. These costs can add up, particularly for villas with extensive grounds or amenities, impacting the overall return on investment.
Renting a Property in Bali
On the flip side, renting property in Bali may seem attractive for tourists and digital nomads as it offers a range of advantages, including flexibility and lower upfront commitments. However, it also comes with certain limitations that might not suit everyone’s long-term plans. Here’s a detailed look at both the benefits and drawbacks of renting property in Bali:
- Flexibility and Ease of Relocation: Renting provides the freedom to move without the long-term commitment of property ownership, making it ideal for those who prefer mobility or are unsure about settling in Bali permanently.
- Lower Upfront Costs: In contrast to buying, renting usually demands just a deposit and monthly payments, making it a more attainable choice for individuals who are not prepared or able to commit to a large financial outlay.
- No Responsibility for Maintenance and Repairs: Typically, landlords handle the upkeep and repairs of the property, relieving tenants from the burden and expense of property maintenance.
- Perfect for Short-term Stays: Renting is ideal for people who plan to stay in Bali for a short period, such as digital nomads, seasonal visitors, or those on short-term contracts.
However, know that renting a property in Bali also means:
- No Long-term Financial Gains: Rent payments contribute to the landlord’s equity, not the tenant’s, meaning there’s no asset accumulation or potential for property value appreciation.
- Lack of Control and Privacy: Tenants may face restrictions regarding property modifications and must adhere to the landlord’s rules, which can limit the sense of personal ownership and privacy.
- Potential for Rent Increases: Upon lease renewal, rental rates may rise, affecting the affordability and stability of the living arrangement.
- Limited Stability and Permanence: Leases come with set durations, implying that tenants may need to renegotiate or relocate often, resulting in a more unstable living situation.
To give you a simplified look, here’s a comparative analysis on both buying and renting options accounting different parameters
| Parameter | Renting | Buying |
|---|---|---|
|
Startup Costs |
Lower: Security deposit, advance rent |
High: Down payment, taxes, legal fees |
|
Additional Costs |
Utilities (sometimes included), potential maintenance fees |
Maintenance, repairs, property taxes (including luxury tax if the property is more than IDR 30 billion) |
|
Hidden Costs |
Possible rent hikes, renewal fees |
Unexpected repairs, fluctuating taxes |
|
Flexibility |
High flexibility, easier to relocate |
Less flexible, selling property can be time-consuming |
|
Value Growth Potential |
None, rent payments do not build equity |
Potential for property appreciation |
|
Financial Stability |
No asset accumulation |
Asset ownership can provide financial security |
|
Risk Management |
Risk of eviction, lease non-renewal |
Market volatility, legal complexities |
Pay 25% of Your Property Straight From Rental Profit
Reduce the financial burden. Use your own villa’s rental income to pay down your investment cost for optimal cash flow and long-term returns
Cost Comparison: Renting vs Buying Property in Bali
When deciding whether to rent or buy property in Bali, it’s essential to weigh the financial implications of each option carefully. Both renting and buying have distinct advantages and challenges, which can significantly affect your overall costs and long-term financial health. Below is an in-depth comparison of the costs associated with each option to help you make a more informed decision.
Renting Costs in Bali
The costs of renting vary widely based on factors like location, property size, and the quality of amenities. Here’s a general breakdown of monthly rental expenses:
- One-bedroom villa: Ranges from $300 to $700 in local neighborhoods, and $800 to $2,000 in popular tourist areas.
- Two-bedroom villa: Costs between $600 and $1,500 in suburban locations, while prime areas like Canggu or Seminyak may charge $2,000 or more.
- Utilities: Expect to pay between $50 and $150 monthly, depending on factors such as air conditioning usage and water consumption.
In short, renting can be a cost-effective choice in the short term, as it requires lower initial expenses compared to buying. However, over the years, the total rental costs can surpass the cost of owning property, especially when considering the lack of asset accumulation and appreciation.
Buying Costs in Bali
Purchasing property in Bali requires a substantial upfront investment and adherence to specific legal regulations for foreigners. Here’s a breakdown of the main costs involved in buying:
- Leasehold Property: A leasehold arrangement, which typically lasts 25 to 50 years, can cost between $50,000 and $300,000, depending on the property’s location and size.
- Freehold Property: Purchasing freehold property, often through a local nominee or PT PMA, can range from $100,000 to over $1,000,000 for villas or luxury homes in desirable areas.
- Additional Costs: Buyers should also budget for legal fees, taxes, and property maintenance, which can collectively amount to 10–15% of the property’s value.
While the initial costs of buying are significantly higher than renting, owning property in Bali can lead to substantial long-term financial benefits. Property ownership allows for asset appreciation and the potential for rental income, making it a worthwhile investment for those with a long-term vision.
So, which option is more cost-effective?
To determine which option is more cost-effective, let’s compare the costs over a 10-year period for a standard two-bedroom villa.
| Expense | Renting | Buying (Leasehold) |
|---|---|---|
|
Initial Costs |
$2,000 (deposit + advance rent) |
$150,000 (purchase price + legal fees) |
|
Annual Rent/Maintenance |
$12,000/year |
$1,500/year (property maintenance) |
|
Total After 10 years |
$122,000 |
$165,000 |
Say you want to stay in Bali for less than 10 years, then renting a property seems to be the more affordable option. However, buying becomes more cost-effective over time, especially if property values appreciate or you generate rental income.
Aside from that, what you really want to achieve as a buyer or renter should also be considered. For instance, if you want to only stay on the island for short-term or if you value flexibility, renting remains the more cost-effective option due to its lower upfront costs and the ability to relocate easily. However, if you’re an expatriate or retired person planning to settle in Bali or seeking a second home, buying property offers greater financial advantages over time. The potential for long-term asset growth, rental income, and the stability that comes with ownership often outweigh the higher initial expenses of purchasing property. Thus, while renting suits short-term needs, buying is a more economical choice for long-term residency and investment.
Construction you can trust
We handle all the details – no hassle for you.
5 Years full warranty
20+ Finished developments in Bali by our team
25+ Years of shared experience
Making Smart Investment Decisions in Bali Real Estate
Aside from knowing your way around the legal and financial requirements of renting and buying properties as well as your investment goals, objectives, and risk appetite, it is also important to know what are the things you must do to ensure a safe and legal transaction.
Verifying land certificates and legal documents
Always ensure that the land certificates and legal documents are authentic and up-to-date. This step is crucial to avoid disputes or legal issues regarding property ownership. Some of the documents you should look for are the owner/seller’s:
- Kartu Tanda Penduduk (Indonesian Identity Card)
- Kartu Keluarga (Family Card)
- Marriage certificate or death certificate (depending on the circumstances of the owner/seller)
- Original certificate of land ownership,
- PBB tax payment (SPPT PBB)
- Tax number (NPWP)
Ensuring proper road access and infrastructure
Verify that the property has adequate road access and infrastructure. Properties without proper access can face significant devaluation and practical challenges.
Complying with zoning laws and building regulations
Adhering to local zoning laws and building regulations is mandatory. Failure to comply can result in hefty fines or demolition orders.
Seeking professional assistance and legal advice
Engage experienced professionals, such as real estate agents and legal advisors, who are well-versed in Indonesian property law to guide you through the process and prevent costly mistakes.
Understanding different property rights and their implications
Familiarize yourself with the various property rights in Indonesia, such as freehold and leasehold, to ensure you choose the option that aligns with your long-term investment goals and legal allowances.
Maximize Your ROI With Data-Driven Management
Benefit from our advanced marketing channels, strong community presence, and direct bookings that outperform standard Airbnb listings.
FAQ
Foreigners cannot directly own freehold property in Bali but can acquire leasehold property or use a Right to Use (Hak Pakai) and Right to Build (Hak Guna Bangunan) structure.
A villa in Bali can cost between IDR 15-50 million ($1,000-$3,500) per month, depending on size, location, and amenities
Yes, property values in Bali have shown consistent growth, and buying one can be a lucrative long-term investment, especially if you rent it out.
Foreigners can typically lease property for 25-99 years, with options for renewal.
Always consult a local legal expert to ensure compliance with property ownership laws and secure proper documentation. Some of the most important things you should do with a legal expert is verifying land certificates, understanding property rights (leasehold vs. freehold), ensuring compliance with zoning laws, and navigating foreign ownership restrictions to ensure a secure and legitimate purchase.
Choose What Fits You Best!
Bali offers an exceptional lifestyle and promising investment opportunities, making both renting and buying viable options depending on your circumstances. Renting provides flexibility, lower upfront costs, and ease of relocation, ideal for short-term stays or those not ready for the commitment of ownership. Conversely, buying property, though involving a higher initial investment and legal complexities, promises long-term financial returns, stability, and the joy of owning a personal haven. By aligning your choice with your financial situation, lifestyle preferences, and future plans, and seeking professional guidance, you can make an informed decision that maximizes your investment in Bali’s vibrant property market.
